Thread: I can have two Xbox 360 games for Christmas, what should one of them be?

I'm getting Skyrim, no doubt about it. Don't even attempt to change my mind. The second, though, is the question. The only kinds of games I don't really like is sports games. My favorite kind of game is open-world games, like Fallout 3, which was literally the best game I've ever played. Absolutely loved it, and also fell in love with Bethesda ever since. What is a really good game that is worthy of my second game? I'm 16 and I like challenges when it comes to games. I was thinking of getting Dark Souls, or Batman: Arkham City, or maybe RAGE (even though I've heard RAGE was boring, so idk). Most of the time, I don't like games that lack a story. Dirt 3 is good, but I can just borrow that from my friend. Maybe Forza 4? I need your guys suggestions. I'm not a fan of games that hand-guide you through stuff either, like Fable 3, which was so easy it was just ridiculous. I already have Gears of War 3, MW3, BF3, Saints Row 3, and Assassins Creed: Revelations, along with all the COD, Assassins Creed, and Gears of War predecessors to those. There are also many old games I have that I didnt list, so just suggest newer games. Thanks.

hmmmm do you prefer some of them?

I would take Skyrim and Batman:AC without a doubt. I am Elder Scrolls freak, and huge Batman fan. Arkham City is addicting and interesting, but if you prefer a long term fun, even after you finish the game, pick Saint's Row 3 instead. Similar to GTA (sandbox, car stealing, gangs), but yet so different in terms of story and concept. And after you finish all missions, you still have bunch of mini quests and stuff to do. I still haven't got bored of it.